Apply

More filters

Commercials for sale in Shelter Island

3,477 available properties

Sort by:

Most relevant first

Most up-to-date first

Most recent published

Price: Lowest first

Price: Highest first

Bedrooms: Lowest first

Bedrooms: Highest first

Size: Lowest first

Size: Highest first

View photo

House

USD 845,000

Town of Shelter Island, Suffolk County

3 Bedrooms

1 Bathroom

901 sq.ft

2 weeks + 3 days ago

14 pictures

Land

USD 1,595,000

Silver Beach, Town of Shelter Island

27,007 sq.ft

Sep 04, 2026

House 231678 results Office 85887 results Apartment 23717 results Ranch 23186 results Townhouse 21471 results Land 15661 results Storage Space 8048 results Cottage 4276 results Farm 4163 results Duplex 3083 results

View photo

House

USD 1,999,999

Shelter Island Heights, Town of Shelter Island

6 Bedrooms

5 Bathrooms

6,098 sq.ft

Sep 02, 2026

18 pictures

House

USD 1,999,999

Shelter Island Heights, Town of Shelter Island

6 Bedrooms

5 Bathrooms

6,098 sq.ft

GardenOffice roomFireplaceAir conditioningSwimming pool

Sep 02, 2026

31 pictures

House

USD 2,239,000

Town of Shelter Island, Suffolk County

6 Bedrooms

4 Bathrooms

3,413 sq.ft

GardenDeckEquipped kitchenParking

Sep 03, 2026

28 pictures

House

USD 2,800,000

Westmoreland, Town of Shelter Island

5 Bedrooms

4 Bathrooms

4,200 sq.ft

GardenGymDeckBalconyFireplaceEquipped kitchenSwimming pool

Aug 27, 2026

View photo

House

USD 8,900,000

Shelter Island Heights, Town of Shelter Island

6 Bedrooms

7 Bathrooms

7,300 sq.ft

ParkingSwimming pool

Aug 23, 2026

View photo

House

USD 4,250,000

Shelter Island Heights, Town of Shelter Island

4 Bedrooms

4 Bathrooms

3,500 sq.ft

Equipped kitchenSwimming pool

Aug 12, 2026

39 pictures

House

USD 4,250,000

Shelter Island Heights, Town of Shelter Island

4 Bedrooms

4 Bathrooms

3,500 sq.ft

Equipped kitchenSwimming pool

Aug 11, 2026

19 pictures

USD 499,000

Shelter Island Heights, Town of Shelter Island

1 Bedroom

1 Bathroom

39,964 sq.ft

GymEquipped kitchenSwimming poolFully furnished

Jul 31, 2026

27 pictures

House

USD 1,500,000

Shelter Island Heights, Town of Shelter Island

5 Bedrooms

2 Bathrooms

2,845 sq.ft

Jul 31, 2026

View photo

House

USD 1,250,000

Town of Shelter Island, Suffolk County

3 Bedrooms

2 Bathrooms

1,608 sq.ft

Office roomEquipped kitchen

Jul 30, 2026

View photo

Updated

House

USD 2,200,000

USD 2,595,000

15%

Shelter Island Heights, Town of Shelter Island

4 Bedrooms

2 Bathrooms

1,994 sq.ft

1 day + 22 hours ago

View photo

Updated

House

USD 4,790,000

USD 4,999,000

Town of Shelter Island, Suffolk County

3 Bedrooms

2 Bathrooms

2,200 sq.ft

2 days + 22 hours ago

View photo

Updated

House

USD 1,445,000

USD 1,495,000

Silver Beach, Town of Shelter Island

3 Bedrooms

2 Bathrooms

1,400 sq.ft

DeckFireplaceEquipped kitchenParking

2 days + 22 hours ago

View photo

House

USD 4,800,000

Town of Shelter Island, Suffolk County

5 Bedrooms

3 Bathrooms

3,325 sq.ft

4 days + 22 hours ago

View photo

House

USD 1,895,000

Town of Shelter Island, Suffolk County

4 Bedrooms

3 Bathrooms

3,484 sq.ft

ParkingFireplaceEquipped kitchen

1 week + 1 day ago

View photo

House

USD 2,239,000

Town of Shelter Island, Suffolk County

6 Bedrooms

4 Bathrooms

3,413 sq.ft

1 week + 1 day ago

View photo

House

USD 3,625,000

Town of Shelter Island, Suffolk County

5 Bedrooms

4 Bathrooms

6,106 sq.ft

Sep 06, 2026

View photo

House

USD 2,800,000

Westmoreland, Town of Shelter Island

5 Bedrooms

4 Bathrooms

4,200 sq.ft

Aug 29, 2026

View photo

House

USD 2,199,000

Town of Shelter Island, Suffolk County

5 Bedrooms

4 Bathrooms

2,646 sq.ft

GardenSwimming poolDeckFireplaceEquipped kitchen

Aug 28, 2026

View photo

House

USD 1,950,000

Hay Beach, Town of Shelter Island

4 Bedrooms

2 Bathrooms

3,059 sq.ft

GardenFireplaceEquipped kitchenParking

Aug 28, 2026

View photo

House

USD 1,999,999

Town of Shelter Island, Suffolk County

4 Bedrooms

3 Bathrooms

2,777 sq.ft

Office roomBalconyEquipped kitchen

Aug 18, 2026

View photo

House

USD 2,199,000

Town of Shelter Island, Suffolk County

5 Bedrooms

4 Bathrooms

2,642 sq.ft

GardenSwimming poolDeckFireplaceEquipped kitchen

Aug 11, 2026

27 pictures

House

USD 2,199,000

Shelter Island Heights, Town of Shelter Island

5 Bedrooms

4 Bathrooms

2,642 sq.ft

GardenSwimming poolDeckFireplaceEquipped kitchen

Aug 07, 2026

View photo

House

USD 2,495,000

Town of Shelter Island, Suffolk County

4 Bedrooms

4 Bathrooms

2,000 sq.ft

FireplaceEquipped kitchen

Aug 04, 2026

View photo

House

USD 2,685,000

Town of Shelter Island, Suffolk County

4 Bedrooms

2 Bathrooms

1,832 sq.ft

DeckBalconyFireplaceEquipped kitchen

Aug 03, 2026

View photo

House

USD 2,150,000

Town of Shelter Island, Suffolk County

4 Bedrooms

2 Bathrooms

2,286 sq.ft

ParkingDeckFireplace

Aug 02, 2026

View photo

House

USD 3,250,000

Town of Shelter Island, Suffolk County

4 Bedrooms

4 Bathrooms

2,950 sq.ft

GardenBalconyFireplaceEquipped kitchen

Jul 29, 2026

26 pictures

House

USD 3,850,000

Hilo Shores, Town of Shelter Island

4 Bedrooms

5 Bathrooms

3,985 sq.ft

DeckFireplaceSwimming pool

Jul 26, 2026

Nearby

Property types

For sale

Shelter Island

Commercials for sale in Shelter Island

Nearby

Commercials Southampton (59,548)

Commercials Orient (58,276)

Commercials Southold (58,186)

Commercials Bridgehampton (58,095)

Commercials Peconic (58,091)

Commercials Amagansett (58,068)

Commercials Mattituck (58,041)

Commercials Cutchogue (58,024)

Commercials Wainscott (58,010)

Commercials Sagaponack (58,005)

Commercials New Suffolk (15,334)

Commercials New York Laurel (5,118)

Commercials South Lyme (4,235)

Commercials East Hampton (3,739)

Commercials East Marion (3,147)

Commercials Old Saybrook (2,190)

Commercials Shelter Island Heights (65)

Property types

Houses Shelter Island (231,678)

Offices Shelter Island (85,887)

Apartments Shelter Island (23,717)

Ranches Shelter Island (23,186)

Townhouses Shelter Island (21,471)

Lands Shelter Island (15,661)

Storage Space Shelter Island (8,048)

Cottages Shelter Island (4,276)

Farms Shelter Island (4,163)

Duplexes Shelter Island (3,083)

For sale

Shelter Island