Filters
Transaction type
House type ApartmentAtticBungalowCabinCommercialCondoCottageDetached HouseDuplexFarmGarageHouseLandOfficeRanchRoomSemi-Detached HouseStorage SpaceTownhouseTriplexVilla
Price
Bedrooms
Bathrooms
Area
Amenities ParkingSwimming poolGardenFireplaceGymOffice roomBalconyTerraceSaunaCellarConcierge
Shelter Island
Clear selection
Shelter Island Shelter Island Heights

Apartments for sale in Shelter Island

60 available properties
Sort by:
Most relevant first
Most relevant first
Most up-to-date first
Price: Lowest first
Price: Highest first
12 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
Apartment
Apartment for sale in Southampton
USD 2,450,000
Southampton
14 mi from Shelter Island

4 Bedrooms

4 Bathrooms

2,700 sq.feet

Fireplace
View details Contact in site

Jun 15, 2025 in realtyWW

12 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
New
Apartment
Apartment for sale in East Hampton
USD 1,295,000
East Hampton
View details

1 day + 16 hours ago in Propriétés le Figaro - Sotheby's International Realty - East Hampton Brokerage

12 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
High demand
Apartment
Apartment for sale in Hampton Bays
USD 1,595,000
Hampton Bays

6 Bedrooms

Swimming pool
View details

4 days + 16 hours ago in Propriétés le Figaro - ANNONCEUR INTERNATIONAL

12 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
Apartment
Apartment for sale in Old Lyme
USD 650,000
Old Lyme
View details

5 days + 16 hours ago in Propriétés le Figaro - William Pitt Sotheby's International Realty

12 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
Apartment
Apartment for sale in Old Saybrook
USD 425,000
Old Saybrook
Swimming pool
View details

1 week + 3 days ago in Propriétés le Figaro - William Pitt Sotheby's International Realty

12 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
High demand
Apartment
Apartment for sale in East Hampton
USD 1,490,000
East Hampton

5 Bedrooms

TerraceSaunaParking
View details

1 week + 4 days ago in Propriétés le Figaro - ANNONCEUR INTERNATIONAL

12 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
Apartment
Apartment for sale in Southampton
USD 2,150,000
Southampton
FireplaceSwimming pool
View details

2 weeks + 6 days ago in Propriétés le Figaro - Sotheby's International Realty - Southampton Brokerage

12 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
Apartment
Apartment for sale in Southampton
USD 2,450,000
Southampton
Fireplace
View details

3 weeks + 16 hours ago in Propriétés le Figaro - Sotheby's International Realty - Southampton Brokerage

12 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
Apartment
Apartment for sale in Orient
USD 1,195,000
Orient
Fireplace
View details

3 weeks + 16 hours ago in Propriétés le Figaro - Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty

12 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
High demand
Apartment
Apartment for sale in Southold
USD 995,000
Southold
GardenBalconyFireplaceParkingSwimming pool
View details

3 weeks + 16 hours ago in Propriétés le Figaro - Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty

12 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
Apartment
Apartment for sale in Westbrook
USD 549,000
Westbrook
View details

3 weeks + 16 hours ago in Propriétés le Figaro - William Pitt Sotheby's International Realty

12 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
Apartment
Apartment for sale in Old Saybrook
USD 695,000
Old Saybrook
Fireplace
View details

3 weeks + 16 hours ago in Propriétés le Figaro - William Pitt Sotheby's International Realty

12 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
Apartment
Apartment for sale in Southampton
USD 999,000
Southampton
12 mi from Shelter Island
Heathcare
At 3 km from Stony Brook Southampton Hospital

2 Bathrooms

116 sq.feet

GardenSwimming pool
View details

Jun 15, 2025 in LuxuryEstate - Vincent Abbate | Nest Seekers LLC

12 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
Apartment
Apartment for sale in Southampton
USD 1,100,000
Southampton
12 mi from Shelter Island

1 Bathroom

114 sq.feet

Garden
View details

Jun 07, 2025 in LuxuryEstate - Tom Ratcliffe | Nest Seekers LLC

12 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
Condo
Condo for sale in Hampton Bays
USD 1,631,000
Hampton Bays
15 mi from Shelter Island

2 Bedrooms

3 Bathrooms

1,717 sq.feet

BalconyFireplace
View details Contact in site

3 days + 16 hours ago in realtyWW

12 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
Condo
Condo for sale in Hampton Bays
USD 1,976,000
Hampton Bays
15 mi from Shelter Island

3 Bedrooms

4 Bathrooms

2,196 sq.feet

BalconyFireplace
View details Contact in site

6 days + 16 hours ago in realtyWW

12 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
Condo
Condo for sale in Hampton Bays
USD 1,583,000
Hampton Bays
15 mi from Shelter Island

2 Bedrooms

3 Bathrooms

1,759 sq.feet

BalconyFireplace
View details Contact in site

1 week + 16 hours ago in realtyWW

12 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
Condo
Condo for sale in Hampton Bays
USD 2,440,000
Hampton Bays
15 mi from Shelter Island

3 Bedrooms

4 Bathrooms

2,638 sq.feet

BalconyFireplace
View details Contact in site

1 week + 3 days ago in realtyWW

12 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
Condo
Condo for sale in Southampton
USD 1,950,000
Southampton
12 mi from Shelter Island
School
At 958 m from Tuckahoe School

4 Bedrooms

4 Bathrooms

2,600 sq.feet

Balcony
View details Contact in site

1 week + 5 days ago in realtyWW

12 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
Condo
Condo for sale in Greenport
USD 629,000
Greenport
3 mi from Shelter Island
Heathcare
At 1 km from Eastern Long Island Hospital

2 Bedrooms

2 Bathrooms

1,300 sq.feet

Swimming pool
View details Contact in site

2 weeks + 3 days ago in realtyWW

12 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
Condo
Condo for sale in Southampton
USD 2,150,000
Southampton
12 mi from Shelter Island
School
At 431 m from Southampton Intermediate and High School

3 Bedrooms

4 Bathrooms

2,500 sq.feet

FireplaceSwimming pool
View details Contact in site

Jun 16, 2025 in realtyWW

12 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
Condo
Condo for sale in Southampton
USD 1,585,000
Southampton
12 mi from Shelter Island
School
At 669 m from Southampton Intermediate and High School

3 Bedrooms

3 Bathrooms

1,600 sq.feet

FireplaceSwimming pool
View details Contact in site

Jun 14, 2025 in realtyWW

10 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
Condo
Condo for sale in East Hampton
USD 1,950,000
East Hampton
9 mi from Shelter Island

3 Bedrooms

3 Bathrooms

Swimming pool
View details Contact in site

Jun 12, 2025 in realtyWW

12 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
Condo
Condo for sale in Hampton Bays
USD 2,198,000
Hampton Bays
15 mi from Shelter Island

3 Bedrooms

4 Bathrooms

1,917 sq.feet

BalconyFireplace
View details Contact in site

Jun 11, 2025 in realtyWW

12 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
Condo
Condo for sale in Southampton
USD 1,100,000
Southampton
12 mi from Shelter Island

2 Bedrooms

2 Bathrooms

1,230 sq.feet

Garden
View details Contact in site

Jun 10, 2025 in realtyWW

12 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
Condo
Condo for sale in Southampton
USD 1,900,000
Southampton
12 mi from Shelter Island
School
At 556 m from Southampton Intermediate and High School

3 Bedrooms

3 Bathrooms

2,364 sq.feet

GardenBalconyFireplaceSwimming pool
View details Contact in site

Jun 08, 2025 in realtyWW

12 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
Condo
Condo for sale in Southold
USD 995,000
Southold
4 mi from Shelter Island

3 Bedrooms

3 Bathrooms

3,735 sq.feet

GardenBalconyFireplaceParkingSwimming pool
View details Contact in site

Jun 07, 2025 in realtyWW

12 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
Condo
Condo for sale in Hampton Bays
USD 1,249,000
Hampton Bays
17 mi from Shelter Island

3 Bedrooms

3 Bathrooms

1,716 sq.feet

View details Contact in site

Jun 07, 2025 in realtyWW

12 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
Condo
Condo for sale in Southampton
USD 6,495,000
Southampton
12 mi from Shelter Island
School
At 914 m from Our Lady of Poland Elementary

4 Bedrooms

5 Bathrooms

5,000 sq.feet

FireplaceParking
View details Contact in site

Jun 07, 2025 in realtyWW

12 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
Condo
Condo for sale in Southampton
USD 1,295,000
Southampton
12 mi from Shelter Island
School
At 776 m from The Montessori School

3 Bedrooms

3 Bathrooms

1,871 sq.feet

BalconyFireplace
View details Contact in site

Jun 07, 2025 in realtyWW

Enter your email and be the first to know about updates on:
Apartments Shelter Island
By suscribing you agree to the terms and conditions and privacy policy
Receive alerts
Give us your email and we'll notify you as soon as we have news about:
Apartments Shelter Island
By suscribing you agree to the terms and conditions and privacy policy Receive alerts
Your search Apartments Shelter Island has been saved
Close