Filters
TRANSACTION TYPE
HOUSE TYPE Apartments Apartment Condo Commercial Commercial Storage Space Detached homes Cottage Detached House House Ranch Land Farm Land Offices Office Rooms Room Semi-detached homes Duplex Townhouse
PRICE
BEDROOMS
BATHROOMS
AREA
AMENITIES Security Security Interior Equipped kitchen Fireplace Office room Air conditioning Cellar Heating Exterior Garden Patio Balcony Terrace Building features Parking Swimming pool Gym Deck Lift Sauna Access for people with disabilities Concierge
IndifferentFurnishedUnfurnishedPartly furnished
PROPERTY SITUATION Bank-Owned Property
IndifferentNear healthcare servicesNear public transportNear schoolsNear nursery schoolsNear beachesNear parks
IndifferentLast dayLast weekLast month

Properties for sale in Shelter Island

307,995 available properties
Sort by:
Most relevant first
Most relevant first
Most up-to-date first
Most recent published
Price: Lowest first
Price: Highest first
Bedrooms: Lowest first
Bedrooms: Highest first
Size: Lowest first
Size: Highest first
View photo Arrow icon pointing to the right
Updated
Foreclosure
House
House for sale in Shelter Island, New York
Request Details
Shelter Island, New York

5 Bedrooms

4 Bathrooms

3,116 sq.ft

18 hours ago

View photo Arrow icon pointing to the right
Updated
Foreclosure
House
House for sale in Shelter Island, New York
Request Details
Shelter Island, New York

18 hours ago

View photo Arrow icon pointing to the right
Updated
Property for sale in Shelter Island, New York
Request Details
Shelter Island, New York

18 hours ago

View photo Arrow icon pointing to the right
Updated
Foreclosure
House
House for sale in Shelter Island, New York
Request Details
Shelter Island, New York

3 Bedrooms

3 Bathrooms

2,184 sq.ft

18 hours ago

View photo Arrow icon pointing to the right
Updated
Property for sale in Shelter Island, New York
Request Details
Shelter Island, New York

18 hours ago

14 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
New
Land
Land for sale in Shelter Island, New York
USD 1,595,000
Shelter Island, New York

27,007 sq.ft

2 days + 18 hours ago

30 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
Updated
House
House for sale in Shelter Island, New York
USD 8,500,000
Shelter Island, New York

4 Bedrooms

1,798 sq.ft

GardenTerraceDeckFireplaceEquipped kitchen

2 days + 18 hours ago

50 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
House
House for sale in Shelter Island, New York
USD 3,100,000
Shelter Island, New York
Swimming pool

4 days + 18 hours ago

View photo Arrow icon pointing to the right
House
House for sale in Shelter Island, New York
USD 1,999,999
Shelter Island, New York

6 Bedrooms

5 Bathrooms

6,098 sq.ft

4 days + 18 hours ago

18 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
House
House for sale in Shelter Island, New York
USD 1,999,999
Shelter Island, New York

6 Bedrooms

5 Bathrooms

6,098 sq.ft

GardenOffice roomFireplaceAir conditioningSwimming pool

4 days + 18 hours ago

View photo Arrow icon pointing to the right
House
House for sale in Shelter Island, New York
USD 845,000
Shelter Island, New York

3 Bedrooms

1 Bathroom

901 sq.ft

5 days + 18 hours ago

33 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
House
House for sale in Shelter Island, New York
USD 2,485,000
Shelter Island, New York
GardenTerraceDeckEquipped kitchenParking

4 days + 18 hours ago

3 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
House
House for sale in Shelter Island, New York
USD 575,000
Shelter Island, New York
Garden

1 week + 4 days ago

38 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
House
House for sale in Shelter Island, New York
USD 3,625,000
Shelter Island, New York

5 Bedrooms

4 Bathrooms

6,106 sq.ft

Office roomEquipped kitchenSwimming pool

1 week + 5 days ago

40 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
House
House for sale in Shelter Island, New York
USD 3,625,000
Shelter Island, New York
Office roomEquipped kitchenSwimming pool

Jul 27, 2026

49 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
House
House for sale in Shelter Island, New York
USD 8,995,000
Shelter Island, New York
GardenDeckSwimming pool

2 weeks + 1 day ago

9 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
House
House for sale in Shelter Island, New York
USD 6,995,000
Shelter Island, New York
GardenEquipped kitchenSwimming pool

2 weeks + 1 day ago

36 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
House
House for sale in Shelter Island, New York
USD 1,300,000
Shelter Island, New York
DeckFireplaceEquipped kitchenParkingSwimming pool

2 weeks + 2 days ago

View photo Arrow icon pointing to the right
House
House for sale in Shelter Island, New York
USD 4,250,000
Shelter Island, New York

4 Bedrooms

4 Bathrooms

3,500 sq.ft

Equipped kitchenSwimming pool

Aug 12, 2026

38 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
House
House for sale in Shelter Island, New York
USD 4,250,000
Shelter Island, New York

4 Bedrooms

4 Bathrooms

3,500 sq.ft

Equipped kitchenSwimming pool

Aug 11, 2026

31 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
House
House for sale in Shelter Island, New York
USD 2,239,000
USD 2,485,000
10%
Shelter Island, New York

6 Bedrooms

4 Bathrooms

3,413 sq.ft

GardenDeckEquipped kitchenParking

3 days + 18 hours ago

28 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
House
House for sale in Shelter Island, New York
USD 2,800,000
USD 2,950,000
5%
Shelter Island, New York

5 Bedrooms

4 Bathrooms

4,200 sq.ft

GardenGymDeckBalconyFireplaceEquipped kitchenSwimming pool

1 week + 3 days ago

View photo Arrow icon pointing to the right
House
House for sale in Shelter Island, New York
USD 8,900,000
Shelter Island, New York

6 Bedrooms

7 Bathrooms

7,300 sq.ft

ParkingSwimming pool

2 weeks + 18 hours ago

19 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
House
House for sale in Shelter Island, New York
USD 1,750,000
Shelter Island, New York

1 Bedroom

1 Bathroom

1,798 sq.ft

GardenSwimming pool

2 weeks + 1 day ago

28 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
House
House for sale in Shelter Island, New York
USD 3,995,000
Shelter Island, New York
Swimming poolCellar

Aug 06, 2026

19 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
Property for sale in Shelter Island, New York
USD 499,000
Shelter Island, New York

1 Bedroom

1 Bathroom

39,964 sq.ft

GymEquipped kitchenSwimming poolFully furnished

Jul 31, 2026

27 pictures Arrow icon pointing to the right
House
House for sale in Shelter Island, New York
USD 1,500,000
Shelter Island, New York

5 Bedrooms

2 Bathrooms

2,845 sq.ft

Jul 31, 2026

View photo Arrow icon pointing to the right
House
House for sale in Shelter Island, New York
USD 1,250,000
Shelter Island, New York

3 Bedrooms

2 Bathrooms

1,608 sq.ft

Office roomEquipped kitchen

Jul 30, 2026

View photo Arrow icon pointing to the right
House
House for sale in Shelter Island, New York
USD 10,750,000
Shelter Island, New York

6 Bedrooms

6 Bathrooms

4,200 sq.ft

FireplaceEquipped kitchenSwimming pool

Jul 28, 2026

View photo Arrow icon pointing to the right
Updated
House
House for sale in Shelter Island, New York
USD 292,200
Shelter Island, New York

4 Bedrooms

3 Bathrooms

3,484 sq.ft

18 hours ago

Enter your email and be the first to know about updates on:
Shelter island
By suscribing you agree to the terms and conditions and privacy policy Receive alerts
Give us your email and we'll notify you as soon as we have news about:
Shelter island
By suscribing you agree to the terms and conditions and privacy policy Receive alerts
Your search Shelter island has been saved
Close