Vacation Rental houses in Shelter Island Heights

Most relevant first

Most up-to-date first

Price: Lowest first

Price: Highest first

We couldn't find results for your search but you might be interested in these listings

14 pictures

Apartment For Sale

Apartment for sale in Shelter Island Heights, New York - Gym

viewed

$ 13,500

Shelter Island Heights, New York

1 bedroom

1 bathroom

Gym

Swimming pool

WSJ

View details

View photo

Apartment For Rent

UPDATED

Apartment for rent in Holbrook, New York - Swimming pool

viewed

$ 2,865

Holbrook, New York

1 bedroom

1 bathroom

864 sq.feet

Swimming pool

1 day + 9 hours ago in RentCafe

View details

2 pictures

Land For Sale

NEW

Land for sale in Shelter Island Heights, New York - Garden

viewed

$ 875,000

Shelter Island Heights, New York

43,560 sq.feet

Garden

Apr 09, 2024 in Weichert Realtors

View details

View photo

Apartment For Rent

UPDATED

Apartment for rent in Moriches, New York - Swimming pool

viewed

$ 3,843

Moriches, New York

2 bedrooms

2 bathrooms

1,199 sq.feet

Swimming pool

RentCafe

View details

View photo

House For Sale

NEW

House for sale in Shelter Island Heights, New York

viewed

Request Details

Shelter Island Heights, New York

1 bathroom

5 days + 9 hours ago in Easyavvisi

View details

View photo

House For Sale

NEW

House for sale in Shelter Island Heights, New York

viewed

Request Details

Shelter Island Heights, New York

1 bathroom

5 days + 9 hours ago in Easyavvisi

View details

View photo

House For Sale

NEW

House for sale in Shelter Island Heights, New York - Swimming pool

viewed

Request Details

Shelter Island Heights, New York

1 bathroom

Swimming pool

5 days + 9 hours ago in Easyavvisi

View details

View photo

Apartment For Rent

UPDATED

Apartment for rent in Moriches, New York - Swimming pool

viewed

$ 1,973

Moriches, New York

1 bedroom

1 bathroom

576 sq.feet

Swimming pool

Sauna

RentCafe

View details

20 pictures

House For Sale

NEW

House for sale in Shelter Island Heights, New York - Car park

viewed

$ 3,250,000

Shelter Island Heights, New York

3 bedrooms

3 bathrooms

1,739 sq.feet

Car park

Swimming pool

Apr 10, 2024 in WSJ

View details

5 pictures

House For Rent

House for rent in Shelter Island Heights, New York - Swimming pool

viewed

$ 25,000

Shelter Island Heights, New York

4 bedrooms

3 bathrooms

Swimming pool

Rentwyre

View details

21 pictures

Apartment For Sale

Apartment for sale in Shelter Island Heights, New York - Car park

viewed

$ 20,000

Shelter Island Heights, New York

5 bedrooms

4 bathrooms

3,225 sq.feet

Car park

Swimming pool

WSJ

View details

View photo

House For Sale

NEW

House for sale in Shelter Island Heights, New York - Swimming pool

viewed

Request Details

Shelter Island Heights, New York

1 bathroom

Swimming pool

Garden

5 days + 9 hours ago in Easyavvisi

View details

4 pictures

For Rent

Property for rent in Shelter Island Heights, New York - Swimming pool

viewed

$ 6,000

Shelter Island Heights, New York

3 bedrooms

2 bathrooms

Swimming pool

Garden

Geebo

View details

View photo

House For Sale

NEW

House for sale in Shelter Island Heights, New York - Garden

viewed

Request Details

Shelter Island Heights, New York

1 bathroom

Garden

5 days + 9 hours ago in Easyavvisi

View details

View photo

Apartment For Rent

UPDATED

Apartment for rent in Long Island City, New York

viewed

$ 4,484

Long Island City, New York

1 bedroom

1 bathroom

626 sq.feet

RentCafe

View details

8 pictures

Apartment For Sale

Apartment for sale in Shelter Island Heights, New York

viewed

$ 50,000

Shelter Island Heights, New York

4 bedrooms

2 bathrooms

2,268 sq.feet

WSJ

View details

View photo

Apartment For Rent

UPDATED

Apartment for rent in New York - Balcony

viewed

$ 1,967

New York

1 bedroom

1 bathroom

576 sq.feet

Balcony

RentCafe

View details

View photo

House For Sale

NEW

House for sale in Shelter Island Heights, New York - Fireplace

viewed

Request Details

Shelter Island Heights, New York

1 bathroom

Fireplace

5 days + 9 hours ago in Easyavvisi

View details

View photo

Apartment For Rent

UPDATED

Apartment for rent in East Norwich, New York

viewed

$ 4,481

East Norwich, New York

2 bedrooms

2 bathrooms

1,234 sq.feet

RentCafe

View details

View photo

Apartment For Rent

UPDATED

Apartment for rent in Brockport, New York

viewed

$ 1,020

Brockport, New York

1 bedroom

1 bathroom

625 sq.feet

RentCafe

View details

View photo

House For Sale

NEW

House for sale in Shelter Island Heights, New York

viewed

Request Details

Shelter Island Heights, New York

1 bathroom

5 days + 9 hours ago in Easyavvisi

View details

View photo

House For Sale

NEW

House for sale in Shelter Island Heights, New York - Swimming pool

viewed

Request Details

Shelter Island Heights, New York

1 bathroom

Swimming pool

Garden

5 days + 9 hours ago in Easyavvisi

View details

View photo

House For Sale

NEW

House for sale in Shelter Island Heights, New York

viewed

Request Details

Shelter Island Heights, New York

3 bedrooms

2 bathrooms

1 week + 5 days ago in AmericanListed

View details

View photo

Apartment For Rent

UPDATED

Apartment for rent in Moriches, New York - Swimming pool

viewed

$ 2,316

Moriches, New York

1 bedroom

1 bathroom

864 sq.feet

Swimming pool

Sauna

RentCafe

View details

30 pictures

House For Sale

House for sale in Shelter Island Heights, New York - Sauna

viewed

$ 62,500

Shelter Island Heights, New York

3 bedrooms

3 bathrooms

2,129 sq.feet

Sauna

WSJ

View details

Receive new listings in your inbox

Receive email alerts

Give us your email and we'll notify you as soon as we have news about

Save