Advanced Search
Search

Houses in Shelter Island

929 houses
57 North Menantic Road, Shelter Island, Usa, Ny
20
House
For Sale
57 North Menantic Road, Shelter Island, Usa, Ny
viewed
$18,000
Shelter Island, New York
1 bathroom
1,790 sq.feet
Splash in the pool, relax on the screened porch or while away the afternoon under the beautiful trees in the back yard of this 3 bedroom, 1.5 bath home which...
Jun 18, 2021 in WSJ - The Corcoran Group
Splash in the pool, relax on the screened porch or while away the afternoon under the beautiful trees in the back yard of this 3 bedroom, 1.5 bath home which...
4 Simpson Road, Shelter Island, Usa, Ny
14
House
For Sale
4 Simpson Road, Shelter Island, Usa, Ny
viewed
$14,000
Shelter Island, New York
2 bathrooms
2,151 sq.feet
Has charm and character that fits right in to this quiet shelter island community...
Jun 18, 2021 in WSJ - The Corcoran Group
Has charm and character that fits right in to this quiet shelter island community...
 Shelter Island, Shelter Island, Usa, Ny
20
House
For Sale
Shelter Island, Shelter Island, Usa, Ny
viewed
$30,000
Shelter Island, New York
2 bathrooms
2,200 sq.feet
Coecles harbor views from dining room, living room, master bedroom, plus 3 additional bedrooms. Amenities include deep water dock, central air, inground pool...
Jun 18, 2021 in WSJ - The Corcoran Group
Coecles harbor views from dining room, living room, master bedroom, plus 3 additional bedrooms. Amenities include deep water dock, central air, inground pool...
10 Bluff Avenue
23
House
For Sale
10 Bluff Avenue
viewed
$2,500,000
Shelter Island, New York
4 bedrooms
2 bathrooms
To the west. 178' sandy beach. Shelter island heights homeowners corp. Includes beach...
Jun 8, 2021 in Weichert Realtors
To the west. 178' sandy beach. Shelter island heights homeowners corp. Includes beach...
 Shelter Island, Shelter Island, Usa, Ny
20
House
For Sale
Shelter Island, Shelter Island, Usa, Ny
viewed
$1,495,000
Shelter Island, New York
2 bathrooms
1,872 sq.feet
3 bedroom, 2.5 bath newly renovated home with open plan living room with fireplace and walk out deck. New kitchen with island breakfast bar and dining area. Charming...
Jun 7, 2021 in WSJ - The Corcoran Group
3 bedroom, 2.5 bath newly renovated home with open plan living room with fireplace and walk out deck. New kitchen with island breakfast bar and dining area. Charming...
7 Lari Lane, Shelter Island
33
House
For Sale
7 Lari Lane, Shelter Island
viewed
$3,995,000
Shelter Island, New York
4 bathrooms
4,301 sq.feet
On shelter island. The illuminated fieldstone walk to the front door crosses a bridge...
Jun 7, 2021 in WSJ - Saunders & Associates
On shelter island. The illuminated fieldstone walk to the front door crosses a bridge...
5 Heritage Drive, Shelter Island
36
House
For Sale
5 Heritage Drive, Shelter Island
viewed
$1,395,000
Shelter Island, New York
2 bathrooms
1,997 sq.feet
Exposed beams, granite counters, center island with seating, recently updated appliances...
Jun 7, 2021 in WSJ - Saunders & Associates
Exposed beams, granite counters, center island with seating, recently updated appliances...
11 Locust Avenue, Shelter Island, Ny
21
House
For Sale
11 Locust Avenue, Shelter Island, Ny
viewed
$1,400,000
Shelter Island, New York
4 bathrooms
2,700 sq.feet
This is an offer for 2 properties one vacant buildable parcel at 8 meadow pl and the adjacent lot improved with a 2400 sf house. Both properties are for...
Jun 7, 2021 in WSJ - Douglas Elliman Real Estate
This is an offer for 2 properties one vacant buildable parcel at 8 meadow pl and the adjacent lot improved with a 2400 sf house. Both properties are for...
 Shelter Island, Shelter Island, Usa, Ny
13
House
For Sale
Shelter Island, Shelter Island, Usa, Ny
viewed
$2,390,000
Shelter Island, New York
2 bathrooms
1,544 sq.feet
Incredible business opportunity, centrally located on 1.62 business zoned acres in the heart of shelter island. A fully equipped kitchen, market and restaurant...
Jun 7, 2021 in WSJ - The Corcoran Group
Incredible business opportunity, centrally located on 1.62 business zoned acres in the heart of shelter island. A fully equipped kitchen, market and restaurant...
101 S Ferry Road, Shelter Island, Us, Ny
34
House
For Sale
101 S Ferry Road, Shelter Island, Us, Ny
viewed
$1,745,000
Shelter Island, New York
5 bathrooms
3,098 sq.feet
A true oasis in beautiful south ferry hills. This 8br/4.5ba home feature breathtaking cathedral ceilings, a gorgeous renovated kitchen w/high end appliances &...
Jun 7, 2021 in WSJ - Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
A true oasis in beautiful south ferry hills. This 8br/4.5ba home feature breathtaking cathedral ceilings, a gorgeous renovated kitchen w/high end appliances &...
15 Montclair Avenue, Shelter Island, Us, Ny
21
House
For Sale
15 Montclair Avenue, Shelter Island, Us, Ny
viewed
$5,300,000
Shelter Island, New York
6 bathrooms
4,545 sq.feet
Kallista kitchen and bar sinks, statuary marble island, sub zero ref. & wine, 36...
Jun 7, 2021 in WSJ - Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
Kallista kitchen and bar sinks, statuary marble island, sub zero ref. & wine, 36...
33 West Neck Road, Shelter Island
32
House
For Sale
33 West Neck Road, Shelter Island
viewed
$895,000
Shelter Island, New York
2 bathrooms
1,267 sq.feet
Located within close proximity to popular sunset beach, ferry, heights and golf, this charming 1899 farmhouse is a wonderful opportunity. A path leads to a...
Jun 7, 2021 in WSJ - Saunders & Associates
Located within close proximity to popular sunset beach, ferry, heights and golf, this charming 1899 farmhouse is a wonderful opportunity. A path leads to a...
91 Ram Island Drive, Shelter Island, Us, Ny
19
House
For Sale
91 Ram Island Drive, Shelter Island, Us, Ny
viewed
$7,995,000
Shelter Island, New York
4 bathrooms
4,640 sq.feet
Of the property. The house itself seems to rise like an island from the water, as was the conceptual... 91 ram island drive is the culmination of twenty years of work by internationally...
Jun 7, 2021 in WSJ - Sotheby's International Realty - Southampton Brokerage
Of the property. The house itself seems to rise like an island from the water, as was the conceptual... 91 ram island drive is the culmination of twenty years of work by internationally...
 Shelter Island, Shelter Island, Usa, Ny
13
House
For Sale
Shelter Island, Shelter Island, Usa, Ny
viewed
$999,000
Shelter Island, New York
2 bathrooms
1,904 sq.feet
Investor opportunity, shy acre with two full houses. Main house has three bedrooms... For a pool. Guest house has two bedrooms, one bathroom, half height full basement...
Jun 7, 2021 in WSJ - The Corcoran Group
Investor opportunity, shy acre with two full houses. Main house has three bedrooms... For a pool. Guest house has two bedrooms, one bathroom, half height full basement...
 Shelter Island, Shelter Island, Usa, Ny
9
House
For Sale
Shelter Island, Shelter Island, Usa, Ny
viewed
$1,420,000
Shelter Island, New York
2,340 sq.feet
Not very often does a business site on shelter island come along for sale. With many different opportunities, this fantastic site located in the business zone...
Jun 7, 2021 in WSJ - The Corcoran Group
Not very often does a business site on shelter island come along for sale. With many different opportunities, this fantastic site located in the business zone...
 Shelter Island, Shelter Island, Usa, Ny
20
House
For Sale
Shelter Island, Shelter Island, Usa, Ny
viewed
$11,995,000
Shelter Island, New York
10 bathrooms
16,000 sq.feet
Dock to ram's island, gardiner's bay and beyond, beautifully imagined by architect... Of a 6 bedroom house, 3 bedroom, 3 car carriage house and 2 story pool house is poised...
May 1, 2021 in WSJ - The Corcoran Group
Dock to ram's island, gardiner's bay and beyond, beautifully imagined by architect... Of a 6 bedroom house, 3 bedroom, 3 car carriage house and 2 story pool house is poised...
 Shelter Island, Shelter Island, Usa, Ny
20
House
For Sale
Shelter Island, Shelter Island, Usa, Ny
viewed
$5,800,000
Shelter Island, New York
6 bathrooms
3,636 sq.feet
Porch that runs across the entire waterside of the house with a separate full... A space that is currently used as a locker room and pool house that has a permit...
Apr 17, 2021 in WSJ - The Corcoran Group
Porch that runs across the entire waterside of the house with a separate full... A space that is currently used as a locker room and pool house that has a permit...
30 Baldwin Road, Shelter Island
23
House
For Sale
30 Baldwin Road, Shelter Island
viewed
$1,595,000
Shelter Island, New York
3 bathrooms
3,304 sq.feet
Located on a shy acre a stone's throw from popular sandy beach, this clean and spacious home with clean lines and abundance of natural light has a decidedly...
Feb 3, 2021 in WSJ - Saunders & Associates
Located on a shy acre a stone's throw from popular sandy beach, this clean and spacious home with clean lines and abundance of natural light has a decidedly...
 Shelter Island, Shelter Island, Usa, Ny
18
House
For Sale
Shelter Island, Shelter Island, Usa, Ny
viewed
$2,795,000
Shelter Island, New York
5 bathrooms
3,072 sq.feet
Located in the sought after shorewood area of shelter island on beautiful mabel's creek, this 5 bedroom, 5 bath home enjoys lovely, serene sanctuary like...
Dec 21, 2020 in WSJ - The Corcoran Group
Located in the sought after shorewood area of shelter island on beautiful mabel's creek, this 5 bedroom, 5 bath home enjoys lovely, serene sanctuary like...
84 N Cartwright Road, Shelter Island, Ny 11964
House
For Sale
84 N Cartwright Road, Shelter Island, Ny 11964
viewed
$749,000
Shelter Island, New York
3 bedrooms
1 bathroom
1,350 sq.feet
Piece of shelter island...
2 days + 23 hours ago in Coldwellbankerhomes
Piece of shelter island...
Undisclosed Address, Shelter Island
House
For Sale
Undisclosed Address, Shelter Island
viewed
$50,000
Shelter Island, New York
4 bathrooms
2,000 sq.feet
Labor day stylishly renovated beach house with spectacular sunrise to sunset water... The house has an enclosed stone courtyard leading to the glass entry which opens on to a spacious...
1 week + 3 days ago in WSJ - Bridgehampton, NY
Labor day stylishly renovated beach house with spectacular sunrise to sunset water... The house has an enclosed stone courtyard leading to the glass entry which opens on to a spacious...
24 S Midway Road, Shelter Island, Ny
House
For Sale
24 S Midway Road, Shelter Island, Ny
viewed
$2,750,000
Shelter Island, New York
5 bathrooms
4,475 sq.feet
A full house generator for peace of mind plus room for a pool complete this move...
2 weeks + 3 days ago in WSJ - Douglas Elliman Real Estate
A full house generator for peace of mind plus room for a pool complete this move...
40b Stearns Point Road
35
For Sale
40b Stearns Point Road
viewed
$6,150,000
$6,750,000
8 %
Shelter Island, New York
7 bedrooms
6 bathrooms
5,800 sq.feet
Of waterfront, the house is perched atop the bluffs of shelter island with views of the sunset beaches that shelter island is famous for. Wander down your private access road...
6 days + 23 hours ago in Compass - Sag Harbor
Of waterfront, the house is perched atop the bluffs of shelter island with views of the sunset beaches that shelter island is famous for. Wander down your private access road...
1 Pandion, Shelter Island, Ny
22
For Sale
1 Pandion, Shelter Island, Ny
viewed
$3,495,000
Shelter Island, New York
On shelter island. The number of home sites has been deliberately reduced to preserve... Residential community on coecles harbor would allow up to a 10,000 sq. Ft. House (subject...
1 week + 3 days ago in WSJ - Compass
On shelter island. The number of home sites has been deliberately reduced to preserve... Residential community on coecles harbor would allow up to a 10,000 sq. Ft. House (subject...
Luxury House For Sale In Shelter Island, United States
10
For Sale
Luxury House For Sale In Shelter Island, United States
viewed
$2,499,000
Shelter Island, New York
This industrial space available for sale sits on 3.66 acres of land, features a 5500 square foot building with multiple bays for use. Currently the property houses...
1 week + 3 days ago in LuxuryEstate - Brown Harris Stevens
This industrial space available for sale sits on 3.66 acres of land, features a 5500 square foot building with multiple bays for use. Currently the property houses...
929 houses
Transaction type
For Sale(844)
For Rent(85)
House type
Last updated
One day ago
One week ago
15 days ago
One month ago
Price: $
 - 
Customize
$0 - $250,000
$250,000 - $500,000
$500,000 - $750,000
$750,000 - $1,000,000
$1,000,000 - $1,250,000
$1,250,000 - $2,000,000
$2,000,000 - $2,750,000
$2,750,000 - $3,500,000
$3,500,000 - $4,250,000
$4,250,000 - $5,000,000
$5,000,000 +
✚ See more...
Bedrooms
1+ bedrooms
2+ bedrooms
3+ bedrooms
4+ bedrooms
Size of the property: sq.feet
 - 
Customize
0 - 45 sq.feet
45 - 90 sq.feet
90 - 135 sq.feet
135 - 180 sq.feet
180 - 225 sq.feet
225 - 360 sq.feet
360 - 495 sq.feet
495 - 630 sq.feet
630 - 765 sq.feet
765 - 900 sq.feet
900+ sq.feet
✚ See more...
Bathrooms
1+ bathrooms
2+ bathrooms
3+ bathrooms
4+ bathrooms
Pictures
With Pictures(877)
Houses in Shelter Island