For rent Shelter Island - 201 Properties for rent in Shelter Island

201 properties for rent

1 Landing Ln, Shelter Island, Ny 11964

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - House - 2,774 sq.feet - 4 bedrooms

Shores area of shelter island. With amazing views from several rooms over west... Throughout this 4 bedroom, 5 bath home will be an incredible home for summer or year round...

2 weeks + 1 day ago in Realtor

See on the map

7 Irene Ln, Shelter Island, Ny 11964

SPONSORED

$16,500

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - House - 2,000 sq.feet - 4 bedrooms

Open floor plan, high ceilings, and great sunlight. Rental permit: 20l-0017 view full listing...

2 weeks + 5 days ago in Realtor

See on the map

Shorewood Cottage Near Wade's Beach

$20,000

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - Apartment - 2 bedrooms - 1 bathroom

Beach house with 2 beds (one with private deck) and 1 bathrooms. Open living room, dedicated dining area room with doors to dining deck and cook's kitchen....

Dec 23, 2020 in Rentdigs

See on the map

Shelter Island Cottage Getaway

$25,000

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - Apartment - 2 bedrooms - 2 bathrooms

An authentic shelter island cottage is waiting for you to come and relax! Offering 2 beds, two baths with dedicated dining area room, open kitchen and living room...

Dec 23, 2020 in Rentdigs

See on the map

West Neck Bay Waterfront

$35,000

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - Apartment - 2 bedrooms - 2 bathrooms

Deck, for early morning coffee, or evening sunsets. Living, kitchen and dining... Evening sunsets. Kayaks are available for use. Rr#: 19s-0028 july 15 - august 31st...

Dec 23, 2020 in Rentdigs

See on the map

Silver Beach With Pool

$13,000

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - Apartment - 3 bedrooms - 1 bathroom

This ranch is located in the much desired silver beach area of shelter island... Eat-in-kitchen and hardwood flooring. Entertainment deck with pool for summer...

Dec 23, 2020 in Rentdigs

See on the map

Ram Island Private Getaway With Heated Pool

$15,000

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - Apartment - 3 bedrooms - 4 bathrooms

One of shelter island’s sought after areas, ram island, is where this up... Kitchen is fully equipped with stainless appliances and a center island to prepare...

Dec 23, 2020 in Rentdigs

See on the map

Coecles Harbor Waterfront With Dock

$2,500

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - Apartment - 4 bedrooms - 3 bathrooms

For swimming, fishing and boating enthusiasts - charming 1916 farmhouse fully updated and situated on a sprawling, private 1.8 acre parcel on shelter island's...

Dec 23, 2020 in Rentdigs

See on the map

Hay Beach Vacation Home With Pool

$15,000

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - Apartment - 4 bedrooms - 3 bathrooms

This 4 beds and 3 bathrooms traditional, located in the hay beach area of shelter island is a wonderful getaway. Newly up-to-date, with the open floor plan of kitchen...

Dec 23, 2020 in Rentdigs

See on the map

Big Ram Waterfront With Pool

$20,000

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - Apartment - 4 bedrooms - 2 bathrooms

This stylish cottage on big ram has forever water views, great sandy beach, open floor plan and outdoor dining atop the waterfront bluff. There is a private...

Dec 23, 2020 in Rentdigs

See on the map

Old Shelter Island Library

$22,000

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - Apartment - 4 bedrooms - 3 bathrooms

This classic was originally the shelter island library until the mid 1960's... Family room, kitchen, dining porch. Expansive deck and wonderful yard for small gatherings...

Dec 23, 2020 in Rentdigs

See on the map

Woodland Setting

$27,000

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - Apartment - 4 bedrooms - 3 bathrooms

Dedicated dining area room and kitchen allowing for easy entertaining and alfresco...

Dec 23, 2020 in Rentdigs

See on the map

Sparkling Traditional On Fresh Pond

$35,000

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - Apartment - 4 bedrooms - 4 bathrooms

Spacious family room on the lower level.Waterside deck invites you for relaxing alfresco...

Dec 23, 2020 in Rentdigs

See on the map

Victorian Carriage House Water Front

$55,000

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - Apartment - 4 bedrooms - 5 bathrooms

Property has been totally rebuilt. An amazing kitchen with a sixteen feet granite island opens onto the dining area with seating for a large party. An welcoming library...

Dec 23, 2020 in Rentdigs

See on the map

Silver Beach Waterviews, Front And Back

$55,000

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - Apartment - 4 bedrooms - 2 bathrooms

Allows for water views of peconic bay, the kitchen glass doors invite you to enjoy...

Dec 23, 2020 in Rentdigs

See on the map

Oriole Farm Dering Harbor Village

$65,000

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - Apartment - 6 bedrooms - 7 bathrooms

That includes space for a sitting area and dedicated dining area area. This is a unique property with every amity for gracious country living. July $65,000, august. - ld $75,000 july...

Dec 23, 2020 in Rentdigs

See on the map

1 S Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, Ny 11964

Request Details

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - House - 5 bedrooms

School district: shelter island high school district: shelter island middle or junior school district: shelter island...

1 day + 12 hours ago in Realtor

See on the map

5 Simpson Ave, Shelter Island, Ny 11964

$10,000

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - House - 2,004 sq.feet - 4 bedrooms

Shelter island shingled cottage convenient to beach and boating. This 4-bedroom... Heated pool. Finished basement for when the extra room is needed. View full listing...

5 days + 17 hours ago in Realtor

See on the map

28 Lake Dr, Shelter Island, Ny 11964

$7,550

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - House - 2,300 sq.feet - 3 bedrooms

26,800 may 1-31st$7,550 short termbeautifully styled home on shelter island's fresh pond. Enjoy days and evenings in this special pond-front home. Cathedral...

5 days + 17 hours ago in Realtor

See on the map

8 E Brander Pkwy, Shelter Island, Ny 11964

$10,000

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - House - 2,280 sq.feet - 5 bedrooms

Country cape waterview with guest cottage rr #19s-012 this charming four bedroom, two bath home features a living room with fireplace, den, country kitchen and...

5 days + 17 hours ago in Realtor

See on the map

7 Marc St, Shelter Island, Ny 11964

$25,000

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - House - 1,200 sq.feet - 2 bedrooms

Newly remodeled modern with pool. Perfect getaway with lovely garden, back deck with outside shower, front deck with full sun, gorgeous kitchen, living room, 2...

6 days + 17 hours ago in Realtor

See on the map

6 Rocky Point Rd, Shelter Island, Ny 11964

$45,000

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - House - 5,500 sq.feet - 6 bedrooms

80,000 august 1st to labor day$45,000 july 1-31stthis incredible property on shelter island sits on a serene and private park like estate of 3.6 acres. Comprised of an historic...

1 week + 1 day ago in Realtor

See on the map

14a Heron Ln, Shelter Island, Ny 11964

$30,000

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - House - 2,000 sq.feet - 3 bedrooms

The layout affords great separation for all bedrooms, each with direct access to outdoor...

1 week + 1 day ago in Realtor

See on the map

12 Dickerson Dr, Shelter Island, Ny 11964

$26,800

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - House - 1,555 sq.feet - 3 bedrooms

Shelter island home with pool and deeded water access 19l-0011. Enjoy your... Space. Well located near the island boatyard marina and menantic creek. View full...

1 week + 2 days ago in Realtor

See on the map

2 Prospect Ave, Shelter Island, Ny 11964

$14,000

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - House - 700 sq.feet - 2 bedrooms

Adirondack cottage in the pines near the beach 19l-0029. One of 3 cottages on this lovely 2.6 acre estate area property. Newly updated with a living room,...

1 week + 4 days ago in Realtor

See on the map

5 E Brander Pkwy, Shelter Island, Ny 11964

Request Details

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - House - 4,495 sq.feet - 5 bedrooms

Mint condition beach house rental registration #2021-l-38 wonderful remodeled... Lower level and open rooms, this is a wonderful home to enjoy for the summer. Lovely...

1 week + 6 days ago in Realtor

See on the map

5 Cove Way, Shelter Island, Ny 11964

$19,000

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - House - 1,305 sq.feet - 3 bedrooms

Or children will awaken to beauty and hidden lawn for yoga. Welcome to the essence of the island... Charming country cottage rental registration #2021-l-37 sail into summer...

1 week + 6 days ago in Realtor

See on the map

7 Hillside Dr, Shelter Island, Ny 11964

SPONSORED

$30,000

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - House - 2,830 sq.feet - 4 bedrooms

Beautifully restored farmhouse with pool stunning 5 bedroom, 3.5 bath farmhouse style home is sited high on a hill in the lovely hilo shores area of shelter island...

2 weeks + 5 days ago in Realtor

See on the map

20a S Cartwright Rd, Shelter Island, Ny 11964

SPONSORED

$25,000

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - House - 1,542 sq.feet - 4 bedrooms

This august rental. Located in the center of the island, this wonderful rental is a minute to all that shelter island has to offer. A must see. View full listing information...

2 weeks + 5 days ago in Realtor

See on the map

4 Glynn Dr, Shelter Island, Ny 11964

SPONSORED

$25,000

Shelter Island, New York - For Rent - House - 2,620 sq.feet - 4 bedrooms

Shelter island fresh contemporary with beach rightsbeautifully decorated and recently renovated 4 bedroom, 3 bath home complete with wrap-around porch, two large...

2 weeks + 5 days ago in Realtor

See on the map

201 properties for rent

Location

New York (95)

┕Any

┕Shelter Island(77)

┕Beaufort(43)

┕San Diego(23)

┕Edmond(9)

┕Sag Harbor(6)

┕Westerly(6)

┕Oklahoma City(3)

┕Shelter Island Heights(3)

┕East Hampton(2)

House type

House

Apartment

Last updated

One day ago

One week ago

15 days ago

One month ago

Price: $

Customize

$0 - $500

$500 - $1,000

$1,000 - $1,500

$1,500 - $2,000

$2,000 - $2,500

$2,500 - $4,000

$4,000 - $5,500

$5,500 - $7,000

$7,000 - $8,500

$8,500 - $10,000

$10,000 +

✚ See more...

Bedrooms

1+ bedrooms

2+ bedrooms

3+ bedrooms

4+ bedrooms

Size of the property: sq.feet

Customize

0 - 45 sq.feet

45 - 90 sq.feet

90 - 135 sq.feet

135 - 180 sq.feet

180 - 225 sq.feet

225 - 360 sq.feet

360 - 495 sq.feet

495 - 630 sq.feet

630 - 765 sq.feet

765 - 900 sq.feet

900+ sq.feet

✚ See more...

Bathrooms

1+ bathrooms

2+ bathrooms

3+ bathrooms

4+ bathrooms

Pictures

With Pictures(200)