Advanced Search
Search

Properties for rent in Shelter Island

Location
New York (204)
Any
Shelter Island(124)
San Diego(48)
Alabaster(23)
Sag Harbor(22)
Hilton Head Island(20)
Edmond(18)
Smithtown(16)
Greenport(14)
Oklahoma City(11)
House type
Last updated
One day ago
One week ago
15 days ago
One month ago
Price: $
 - 
Customize
$0 - $500
$500 - $1,000
$1,000 - $1,500
$1,500 - $2,000
$2,000 - $2,500
$2,500 - $4,000
$4,000 - $5,500
$5,500 - $7,000
$7,000 - $8,500
$8,500 - $10,000
$10,000 +
✚ See more...
Bedrooms
1+ bedrooms
2+ bedrooms
3+ bedrooms
4+ bedrooms
Size of the property: sq.feet
 - 
Customize
0 - 45 sq.feet
45 - 90 sq.feet
90 - 135 sq.feet
135 - 180 sq.feet
180 - 225 sq.feet
225 - 360 sq.feet
360 - 495 sq.feet
495 - 630 sq.feet
630 - 765 sq.feet
765 - 900 sq.feet
900+ sq.feet
✚ See more...
Bathrooms
1+ bathrooms
2+ bathrooms
3+ bathrooms
4+ bathrooms
Pictures
With Pictures(390)
101 properties for rent
View photo
House For Rent
House for rent in Shelter Island, New York
$ 50,000
Shelter Island, New York
5 bedrooms
1,550 sq.feet
ListedBuy
View details
View photo
House For Rent
House for rent in Shelter Island, New York - Garden
$ 38,000
Shelter Island, New York
4 bedrooms
1,259 sq.feet
Garden
ListedBuy
View details
View photo
House For Rent
House for rent in Shelter Island, New York - Balcony
$ 38,000
Shelter Island, New York
4 bedrooms
1,345 sq.feet
Balcony
Swimming pool
ListedBuy
View details
View photo
House For Rent
House for rent in Shelter Island, New York
$ 50,000
Shelter Island, New York
3 bedrooms
1,691 sq.feet
ListedBuy
View details
View photo
House For Rent
House for rent in Shelter Island, New York - Balcony
$ 40,000
Shelter Island, New York
3 bedrooms
840 sq.feet
Balcony
Fireplace
ListedBuy
View details
View photo
House For Rent
House for rent in Shelter Island, New York - Garden
$ 32,000
Shelter Island, New York
3 bedrooms
883 sq.feet
Garden
ListedBuy
View details
View photo
House For Rent
House for rent in Shelter Island, New York - Swimming pool
$ 13,000
Shelter Island, New York
3 bedrooms
958 sq.feet
Swimming pool
ListedBuy
View details
View photo
House For Rent
House for rent in Shelter Island, New York
$ 24,750
Shelter Island, New York
4 bedrooms
1,012 sq.feet
ListedBuy
View details
View photo
House For Rent
House for rent in Shelter Island, New York - Balcony
$ 50,000
Shelter Island, New York
3 bedrooms
1,012 sq.feet
Balcony
Swimming pool
ListedBuy
View details
View photo
House For Rent
House for rent in Shelter Island, New York - Car park
$ 4,500
Shelter Island, New York
3 bedrooms
840 sq.feet
Car park
Fireplace
Garden
ListedBuy
View details
18 pictures
House For Rent
House for rent in Shelter Island, New York - Fireplace
$ 35,000
Shelter Island, New York
4 bedrooms
3,194 sq.feet
Fireplace
Swimming pool
Garden
1 week + 13 hours ago in Listanza
View details
22 pictures
House For Rent
House for rent in Shelter Island, New York - Fireplace
$ 60,000
Shelter Island, New York
3 bedrooms
2,000 sq.feet
Fireplace
1 week + 5 days ago in Listanza
View details
22 pictures
House For Rent
UPDATED
House for rent in Shelter Island, New York - Garden
$ 18,000
Shelter Island, New York
2 bedrooms
650 sq.feet
Garden
Listanza
View details
13 pictures
House For Rent
House for rent in Shelter Island, New York - Fireplace
$ 30,000
Shelter Island, New York
3 bedrooms
1,750 sq.feet
Fireplace
Garden
Listanza
View details
8 pictures
House For Rent
House for rent in Shelter Island, New York
$ 35,000
Shelter Island, New York
4 bedrooms
2,799 sq.feet
1 week + 6 days ago in Listanza
View details
24 pictures
House For Rent
House for rent in Shelter Island, New York - Car park
$ 16,500
Shelter Island, New York
5 bedrooms
4,700 sq.feet
Car park
Fireplace
Swimming pool
Listanza
View details
8 pictures
Condo For Rent
UPDATED
Condo for rent in Shelter Island, New York - Garden
$ 12,000
Shelter Island, New York
4 bedrooms
1,300 sq.feet
Garden
Listanza
View details
24 pictures
House For Rent
House for rent in Shelter Island, New York - Swimming pool
$ 20,000
Shelter Island, New York
5 bedrooms
2,720 sq.feet
Swimming pool
Garden
Listanza
View details
22 pictures
House For Rent
UPDATED
House for rent in Shelter Island, New York - Balcony
$ 34,000
Shelter Island, New York
4 bedrooms
2,974 sq.feet
Balcony
Fireplace
Listanza
View details
8 pictures
House For Rent
House for rent in Shelter Island, New York - Fireplace
$ 14,000
Shelter Island, New York
4 bedrooms
2,280 sq.feet
Fireplace
Listanza
View details
15 pictures
House For Rent
UPDATED
House for rent in Shelter Island, New York - Garden
$ 39,000
Shelter Island, New York
3 bedrooms
1,636 sq.feet
Garden
Listanza
View details
20 pictures
House For Rent
UPDATED
House for rent in Shelter Island, New York
$ 22,000
Shelter Island, New York
5 bedrooms
2,265 sq.feet
Listanza
View details
9 pictures
House For Rent
UPDATED
House for rent in Shelter Island, New York
$ 25,000
Shelter Island, New York
3 bedrooms
2,014 sq.feet
Listanza
View details
17 pictures
House For Rent
House for rent in Shelter Island, New York - Swimming pool
$ 47,000
Shelter Island, New York
3 bedrooms
2,180 sq.feet
Swimming pool
1 week + 6 days ago in Listanza
View details
20 pictures
House For Rent
House for rent in Shelter Island, New York - Swimming pool
$ 60,000
Shelter Island, New York
3 bedrooms
2,200 sq.feet
Swimming pool
1 week + 6 days ago in Listanza
View details
101 properties for rent